close icon
Kitchens

Choosing Your Luxury Kitchen: Traditional Craftsmanship vs. German Engineering

When it comes to high-end kitchens, the choices are as vast as the ingredients in a Michelin-starred pantry. But today, let’s streamline the debate to two of the most coveted styles: the classic, handmade English kitchen, and the sleek, German-engineered contemporary kitchen.

By Alexandra Ashley November 2024

So, which is right for you? A traditional or Shaker-style kitchen is rooted in history, often associated with meticulous craftsmanship and the shaker movement of the 18th century. Meanwhile, a German-engineered kitchen delivers streamlined functionality with a flair for the futuristic. Here, we’ve provided a deep dive into the design, craftsmanship, and lifestyle suited to each of these opulent kitchens.

shaker kitchen
modern kitchen

Traditional Craftsmanship: The Shaker-Style Kitchen

Imagine entering a Georgian or Victorian townhouse, perhaps with a checkerboard hallway and lofty ceilings. These spaces call for a kitchen that is as timeless as the architecture, where subtle sophistication meets classic elegance. Here, a Shaker or traditional kitchen shines. Alternatively, picture a detached barn conversion, isolated in nature, or even a quaint cottage nestled among dense woodlands in the British countryside. A traditional kitchen here feels as natural as the view from its windows. With painted wood cabinets, exposed beams, and perhaps an Aga stove softly humming in the corner, this kitchen complements the rustic charm around it. It’s a place where vintage copper pots dangle from hooks, wildflowers sit in mason jars, and the heart of the home beats in tune with the seasons—a timeless space that invites you to slow down, savor, and make every meal a ritual.

 

traditional kitchen
traditional kitchen

What Makes a Shaker Kitchen Special?

Shaker kitchens prioritise simplicity, quality, and function. Built with hardwood and crafted by hand, they showcase dovetail joints, in-frame cabinets, and a subdued color palette. Think of hues from sage green to deep navy or, for purists, an array of whites and grays. This type of kitchen whispers refinement; it’s about embracing imperfections, seeing them as marks of character rather than flaws. Each piece feels like it’s been around for decades and will continue to endure, aging gracefully with time.

Who Is the Traditional Kitchen For?

This kitchen appeals to the “discerning minimalist” who values legacy over trends. Perhaps you’re a lover of historical novels or classic films, someone who finds satisfaction in knowing every cabinet is solid oak rather than plywood. You might have a penchant for traditional décor but are anything but dull. This kitchen serves those who appreciate the slow-cooked approach, who favor cast iron over Teflon, and are known to have a roast on Sunday, even if they’re out for brunch the rest of the week.

 

shaker kitchen
shaker kitchen

The Ideal Setting

These kitchens are perfectly at home in period properties, country houses, and converted barns. But working alongside a  savvy designer holds the potential to also bring this warmth and craftsmanship into more modern spaces by adding contemporary lighting and high-end, subtly integrated appliances.

A Traditional Kitchen’s Appeal

These kitchens feel curated and storied, with rich, handcrafted cabinetry and luxurious finishes that create a warm yet refined ambiance. Every element, from the solid wood doors to the classic brass fixtures, speaks of enduring beauty, offering an expensive look and feel that’s truly timeless—an investment that only deepens in character and charm as the years go by.

A Fine Example

To see our designer’s take on the way a traditonal kitchen can enhance the architcture of a real Georgian house in the countryside, see The Rose Garden Project.

traditional kitchen

German-Engineered Elegance: The Modern Kitchen

On the other end of the spectrum lies the German-engineered contemporary kitchen: think sleek lines, handleless cabinetry, and appliances that could probably beat your smartphone in a game of chess. These kitchens are architectural statements as much as culinary playgrounds, making a bold statement without shouting.

 

modern kitchen
modern kitchen

What Makes a German Kitchen Special?

Precision is at the heart of German kitchen design. These spaces are crafted with the efficiency of a Formula 1 engine and the elegance of a Berlin art gallery. Often minimalist in aesthetic, the cabinetry is typically finished with high-gloss lacquer, matte finishes, or even glass. Everything has its place, and functionality is paramount. Here, you’ll find pocket doors, pull-out pantries, hidden compartments, and – if you’re truly committed – pop-up downdraft extractors. If a kitchen can ever feel like it’s on the cutting edge of design, this is it.

Who Is the Modern Kitchen For?

This kitchen is for the “design-conscious innovator,” who values clean lines, technology, and high function. Perhaps you’re someone who enjoys smart home gadgets, shops by gallery hopping, and prefers a seamless wine fridge over a visible spice rack. You embrace efficiency and have an eye for detail; you see the kitchen as an extension of your tech-savvy and polished lifestyle. This isn’t to say you don’t appreciate good design – quite the opposite. You simply favor cutting-edge over nostalgic.

 

modern kitchen
modern kitchen

The Ideal Setting

This style is an obvious choice for new builds, penthouses, lofts, or contemporary homes. It’s particularly striking in open-plan spaces where the kitchen can blend with living and dining areas. It’s made for clean architectural lines, wide floor-to-ceiling windows, and uncluttered spaces that allow the kitchen’s precision to truly stand out.

A Modern Kitchen’s Appeal

Here, beauty meets brawn. High-specification materials like quartz, glass, and brushed steel keep things both aesthetically pleasing and practical. Imagine a countertop that repels stains, a cabinet that opens with a nudge, and lighting that adjusts to set the perfect evening ambiance. It’s a bit like stepping into a spaceship designed by Bauhaus.

See it in Action

Witness a German-designed, engineered, and crafted kitchen in action, effortlessly blending into a flat’s sleek interior in The Elmhurst Project

modern kitchen
Meet the author

Alexandra Ashley

One of our four kitchen designers, with a background in industrial and interior design. Ali is a regular author for our Articles, offering poignant insights into the industry.

Start the conversation

Request a call back from one of our specialists who will take care of everything. We'll even send you a complimentary digital brochure.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name
Acceptance
TOP